Monmouth Trading Cards

Retail Store Head Buyer

Monmouth Trading Cards  •  $18 - $22/hr  •  East Brunswick, NJ (Onsite)  •  4 hours ago
Apply
AI can make mistakes so check important info. Chat history is never stored.

Job Description

Benefits:

  • Employee discounts
  • Flexible schedule
  • Free food & snacks
  • Free uniforms
  • Health insurance
  • Opportunity for advancement
  • Training & development

Job Title:

Head Buyer – Trading Cards & Collectibles

Location

East Brunswick, NJ

Company:

Monmouth Trading Cards

Overview

Monmouth Trading Cards is seeking an experienced, highly organized Head Buyer to join our East Brunswick location. In this leadership role, you will spearhead our purchasing operations by evaluating collections, negotiating deals directly with customers, and managing the end-to-end logistics of every acquisition. You will thrive in a fast-paced collectibles environment, balancing sharp market knowledge with meticulous attention to paperwork, inventory intake, and timely shipping.

Key Responsibilities

  • Customer Negotiations & Purchasing: Evaluate single cards, sealed products, and full collections brought in by customers; negotiate fair, profitable purchase prices while delivering a transparent, positive customer experience.
  • Documentation & Compliance: Accurately complete, verify, and file all required purchase paperwork, intake logs, receipts, and compliance documentation for every buy.
  • Packing & Shipping Logistics: Carefully pack purchased collections and outbound shipments to ensure high-value items are protected, coordinating timely dispatch to meet operational deadlines.
  • Inventory & Organization: Maintain a strict, well-organized system for tracking incoming buys, sorting inventory, and keeping the buying station and storage areas clean and orderly.
  • Market Valuation: Stay up to date on current trading card market trends, card grading standards, and real-time pricing to make informed buying decisions.
  • Team Collaboration: Work closely with retail and warehouse staff to transition purchased inventory smoothly into store displays or online sales channels.

Qualifications

  • Strong Organizational Skills: Proven ability to manage multiple ongoing buys, detailed paperwork, and shipping schedules simultaneously without letting details slip through the cracks.
  • Negotiation & Communication: Confident, persuasive, and personable communicator capable of building trust with collectors while protecting company margins.
  • Trading Card Expertise: Deep knowledge of sports cards, TCGs (Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, etc.), card condition grading, and current market valuation tools.
  • Logistics & Packing Experience: Hands-on experience safely packing fragile or high-value collectibles and managing outbound shipping workflows on tight timelines.
  • High Attention to Detail: High level of accuracy when handling cash/payouts, logging serial numbers or card lists, and processing intake forms.
  • Prior buying, retail management, or collectibles industry experience strongly preferred.

What Success Looks Like

  • Consistent, profitable acquisitions built through fair and friendly customer negotiations.
  • 100% accurate, complete, and properly filed paperwork for every transaction.
  • Purchased items packed securely and shipped out on schedule with zero damage or delays.
  • A streamlined, clutter-free, and easily traceable intake and inventory organization system.

Compensation: $18.00 - $22.00 per hour

Monmouth Cards is one of the fastest-growing names in trading cards and collectibles. We sell across multiple retail locations in NJ, CT, and MA, online through our own store and major marketplaces, and live every week through streaming — meeting collectors wherever they are in the hobby, from first packs to high-end slabs.

What sets us apart is how we operate. We move fast, sweat the details, and treat product knowledge and customer experience as the whole job, not an afterthought. Our team is made up of people who actually care about the hobby and bring real energy to every break, sale, and store visit.

We're at a stage where the work is varied, the pace is quick, and the people who lean in get to grow with us. If you want to be part of building something real in the card space — not just clock in — you'll fit right in here.

Monmouth Trading Cards

About Monmouth Trading Cards

At Monmouth Trading Cards, we’re more than a card shop — we’re a hub for collectors, investors, and fans who live and breathe the hobby. Based in New Jersey, we specialize in buying, selling, and curating premium sports trading cards, sealed wax, and memorabilia, both in-store and online.

We proudly operate cutting-edge retail stores, run high-energy livestream sales, and supply some of the largest breakers, shops, and marketplaces in the hobby. Whether you're a passionate collector chasing grails or a business looking to source high-quality product, Monmouth Trading Cards is your trusted partner.

Our team combines deep industry knowledge with an obsession for customer experience. We’re constantly innovating — from tech-driven inventory management to exclusive product drops — to elevate the way people buy, sell, and experience the hobby.

Let’s connect. Let’s rip. Let’s grow the hobby together.

Industry
Retail & Ecommerce
Company Size
11-50 employees
Headquarters
Unknown
Year Founded
Unknown
Social Media