NYCM Insurance

Law Office Supervisor (Hybrid)

NYCM Insurance  •  New York (Hybrid)  •  4 hours ago
Apply
AI can make mistakes so check important info. Chat history is never stored.

Job Description

The Law Office Supervisor will supervise, plan, and coordinate work on tasks assigned to support staff in the Edmeston and Orchard Park attorney offices. They are the liaison with the home office and provide updates on currency dates and productivity levels. The Law Office Supervisor is responsible for creating, encouraging, and supporting a friendly, supportive, and professional environment. They assist attorneys in researching and analyzing pertinent law documents.

Duties & Responsibilities:

  • Manage team by providing guidance, coaching, and oversight of duties, defining goals, communicating objectives and monitoring team performance.
  • Assess the capacity, productivity, quality, as well as the ability of the Support Staff and Paralegals to meet attorney needs.
  • Assist with staff maintenance through recruiting, selecting, orienting, promoting, handle employee grievances or discipline, and any necessary terminations.
  • Verify and approve timekeeping records and consult employees about any discrepancies.
  • Document performance feedback and other personnel matters.
  • Report to division management currency dates for all major work items on a weekly basis or as requested.
  • Maintains record of assignments, attorney calendars, and paralegal schedules so that the department may provide optimum and continuous support on all assigned cases.
  • Directly oversee case management by ensuring files are organized, deadlines are managed, and cases are kept on track
  • Responsible for developing, updating, adjusting and maintaining legal processes and procedures and support file handling and workflow in conjunction with management for continuous timely, efficient, and best practice work efforts in response to fluctuations in workload, staffing, and last-minute staff attorney requests.
  • Improve service quality by gathering regular feedback from attorneys and company business units. Coordinate with casualty department to effectively and efficiently meet the needs on each file assigned.
  • Directly assist attorneys with legal matters and oversee paralegal work.
  • Design and implement systems and processes to conduct research, gather/organize medical records, and produce legal documents for attorneys.
  • Regularly track, report, and adjust service based on metrics.
  • Develop and monitor an efficient workflow, training, and QA process for all work in the office.
  • Oversee submission and payment of vendor invoices while directly addressing all problem invoices with vendor.
  • Complete any assigned special projects
  • Other duties as assigned.

Requirements:

  • High school diploma, or equivalent, with related experience demonstrating the knowledge, skills, and abilities necessary to perform the essential functions of the position

Skills & Qualifications:

  • Strong knowledge of civil litigation process.
  • Experience and ability to redistribute work as necessary to effectively deal with the fluctuating work demands of a fast-paced litigation practice and the ability to adapt to requests that come up on cases with limited notice.
  • Proficient personal computer skills including electronic mail, record keeping, routine database activity, Microsoft Word, PowerPoint and Excel.
  • Strong, effective, and professional oral, listening, and written communication skills.
  • Good leadership skills with tactful, professional manner under pressure.
  • Strong documentation, attention to detail, organizational, time management, skills.
  • Ability to set and prioritize workflow, shift priorities as necessary, follow through on open items, and meet deadlines on multiple projects.
  • Sound problem solving skills.
  • Ability to teach and train support duties.
  • Ability to work independently and in a team environment and adapt well to changing work environment.

Market Range: 9 / 40 hours per week / Hybrid - 3 days in office

Salary: $59,819 - $96,375

Accepting applications through: 9/17/26

NYCM Insurance

About NYCM Insurance

NYCM Insurance is a property and casualty insurance carrier that has been providing coverage to residents and businesses in New York since 1899. With a team of over 975 employees, and a network of over 1,400 independent agents, NYCM is dedicated to providing superior service and a quality customer experience.

Our story began in Edmeston, NY – a tiny rural town known for its agricultural community – when one farmer lost everything in a fire. Realizing that the town needed to be better prepared for the future, 27 businessmen and residents came together to pool money and protect one another from fires and lightning, officially establishing the New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company under founder VanNess D. Robinson in 1899.

We are a family founded and run company and believe in staying true to our small-town roots. Over 120 years later, we’re still operating in our original town of Edmeston, NY and have expanded to include three additional offices in Sherburne, Orchard Park and Canajoharie, further investing ourselves in New York State and our local communities.

We are also highly invested in our 900+ employees. We know that our best work comes from an inspired internal culture and our drive to succeed as a team.

Between our employee base and a network of over 1,200 independent agents, NYCM Insurance is proud to service over 525,000 insureds. Our insurance lines include Home, Auto, Umbrella, Commercial and more.

NYCM Insurance is proud to work with various partners to offer additional types of coverage for many areas of your life including special events, motorcycles, off-road vehicles, bicycles, yachts, collector cars and more. These partnerships help us ensure that you and yours are always protected no matter what life throws at you.

At the end of the day, our reason for doing business is the same as it was 120 years ago. We believe in providing genuine care; so that we can all have hope for a better tomorrow and the courage to persevere.

Industry
Finance & Insurance
Company Size
201-500 employees
Headquarters
Edmeston, NY
Year Founded
1899
Website
nycm.com
Social Media